One primary area of contention was the selection of characters. Fans appreciated the large roster, which included a mix of fan-favorite characters like Ichigo Kurosaki, Rukia Kuchiki, and Byakuya Kuchiki. However, some questioned the inclusion of lesser-known or minor characters over more prominent ones. For instance, characters from the earlier arcs were prioritized, while iconic individuals from later storylines, such as the Hueco Mundo arc, were absent from certain games. This limitation, likely due to the timing of the games' development relative to the anime's progression, left fans disappointed, as some felt their favorite characters were overlooked.

Another major debate stemmed from the story arcs included in the games, particularly the use of non-canon or filler content. While the main Bleach DS titles featured storylines aligned with the anime, Bleach: Dark Souls introduced an original story that diverged from the established canon. While this move was intended to provide fresh content and maintain player engagement, some fans felt that it diluted the connection to the source material. Critics argued that these non-canon elements lacked the depth and emotional resonance of the original arcs, reducing the narrative's overall impact.

Despite these controversies, the Bleach DS games remain beloved by fans for their fast-paced combat and authentic Bleach aesthetic. While some creative decisions may have sparked debates, they also reflect the challenges of adapting a sprawling and beloved series into an interactive format. These discussions highlight the passion of the Bleach fanbase and the high expectations they hold for any adaptation of their cherished series.